Clos Frantin (Bichot) Vosne-Romanée 1er cru Malconsorts 2016

94-95 points James Suckling: "Beautiful crushed roses with an array of fresh raspberries and red cherries, as well as light mocha and oak spices in the background. The palate has excellent tannin maturity and depth. A bold, explosive finish. This is exceptional. This elegant vintage has delivered a wine with real clarity and detail. But still needs some time. Try from 2024. (2/15/18)"

94 points Jasper Morris, MW: "Significantly rich deep purple. A wonderful richness of flavour sweeps across the palate in a way that didn’t quite happen with their Amoureuses. It is still held in check a bit by the wood. A solid, rich, firm wine at the finish, with impressive density. (Jan 2018)"

94 points Tim Atkin, MW (Jan 2018).

94 points Anne Krebiehl (The World of Fine Wine): "Underneath, a touch of iron oxide, of crushed peony, of cherry freshness. The palate has assertive firmness but comes on light feet. The finish echoes long and intrigues with layers of brooding beauty. (Issue 59; 2018)"

93 points Stephen Brook (Decanter): "The nose is intense but still severe, with minty, oaky aromas wrestling the cherry fruit. It's very concentrated and powerful, and has swagger and energy, perhaps at the expense of some refinement. There's ample extract here but no toughness, and good length. Drink: 2020-2040. Alcohol 13.5%. (Apr 2019)"