Selosse Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Les Carelles Mesnil sur Oger NV

100 points Kristaps Karklins (Wine Advocate): "Based on the 2017 vintage, the NV Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil-sur-Oger Les Carelles is the crowning achievement of an extraordinary lineup of Jacques Selosse lieux-dits this year and entirely transcends the reputation typically associated with the base year. Disgorged in January 2024 without dosage, it derives from two plots (pressed together) in the same lieu-dit: the smallest south- facing plot yielding small, concentrated berries and the larger, facing east. Les Carelles was one of the first wines of Selosse I ever tasted, back when it was still a novelty in the range, and I vividly remember the emotions it evoked—I had never tasted Le Mesnil like this before. Exploding from the glass and revealing a bouquet of kaleidoscopic complexity, it offers aromas of ripe citrus fruit, pine resin, dried fig, smoke and tangerine. Elegantly charming, with tangy underlying acidity, it concludes with a long, chalky finish. Based on a historical blend started in 2003, with the youngest wine from 2017, it’s a seamless rendition, uniting the generosity of perpetual component and the amplitude of the year with the tension of the site. As always, the base vintage (about 60% of the final blend) is aged for 10 months in 228-liter barrels (around 20% new), then briefly blended in a concrete tank with the perpetual component, which is stored in 12-hectoliter foudre (as are all the lieux-dits, with the exception Les Chantereines and Chemin de Chalons, which are kept in eight-hectoliter foudre). After refilling the foudre, the rest is bottled, meaning the quantity per year varies, based on generosity and quality of the vintage. Champagne doesn’t get much better than this—it’s worth every effort to seek out. Drink 2024-2039 (Dec 2024)"

97 points La Revue du Vin de France: "Les Carelles has a very different expression: dried fruits, hazelnuts, with a chalky feel. On the palate, it's the Mesnil terroir that expresses itself in this long, worn-out structure. The right mineral restraint, without austerity, brings persistence. (2025)"

97 points Bettanne & Desseauve (2025).