Damascene Syrah Stellenbosch Western Cape 2022

97 points Tim Atkin, MW: "[13.1%] “Syrah is in my blood," says Jean Smit, and it shows. This is one of a trio of brilliant examples of the variety, combining grapes from the Polkadraai Hills with 20% from Bottelary. Bloody, intense, brooding and almost indecently aromatic, it's a tribute to the great reds of the northern Rhône, with plenty of granitic grip, tapenade, liquorice and blackberry flavours and the structure and focus to age beautifully in bottle. 2027-2040. (2024)."

95 points Neal Martin (Vinous): "The 2022 Syrah from Karabib is 75% whole clusters matured for 11 months in 2,000-liter Austrian oak. This elegant nose of incense and pressed violets infuses the vivacious melange of black and blue fruit. The medium-bodied palate has fine structure, slightly chalky in texture, with real backbone and density, yet the elegance floods through on the black pepper and clove-infused finish. Very persistent in the mouth. Tuck bottles away for several years as this is a serious Syrah sculpted by its cooler microclimate. Drink 2028-2048. (Aug 2023)."

93 points James Suckling: "Scented and authentic with aromas of dark cherries, plums, black pepper, smoke and dried violets. Full body with chewy tannins. Dense and compact with character and an intense development of dark berries and spices on the mid-palate. Focused and serious finish with excellent length. Drink or hold. (12/10/23)."