La Conseillante Pomerol 2004

94 points Jane Anson (Decanter): "This is definitely still in the younger phase, with plenty of primary fruit notes that are just starting to budge from tight cassis and black pepper spice to gentler blackberry and black truffle. It has lovely precise black fruits, showcasing the excellence of La Conseillante's winemaking and terroir. There's good persistency and reassuring grip too, finishing with a lovely black truffle note. It has a good 10-15 years ahead of it. Drinking Window: 2018-2034. (Dec 2017)"

93 points Neal Martin (Vinous): "The 2004 La Conseillante took a little time to settle in the glass but eventually reveals pretty red brambly fruit mixed with wild hedgerow, broom and graphite. With aeration it musters more and more precision, so decanting is advisable for this vintage. The palate is showing very well. It has a surprising structure and plenty fruit, suggesting this is one of the longer-term La Conseillantes. It is fresh and tensile from the start thanks to a razor-sharp thread of acidity whilst there is a newfound sense of precision felt on the finish. This is a great La Conseillante – perhaps one of the most underrated of this decade. Drink: 2018-2034. (May 2018)"

92 points Wine Spectator: "Perfumed and subtle, with blackberry, chocolate and light vanilla. Full-bodied, yet not a blockbuster, with wonderful, caressing mouthfeel and a medium-to-long finish. Balanced and refined. Best after 2010. (3/31/07)"